Penny's Cafe Menu (Update 2026)

One egg any style, sausage or bacon, grits or hash browns, toast or biscuit

Two eggs any style, sausage or bacon, grits or hash browns, toast or biscuit

Three eggs any style, sausage or bacon, grits or hash browns, toast or biscuit

Two pancakes, two eggs any style, sausage or bacon, grits or hash browns, toast or biscuit

Two grilled or breaded pork chops, two eggs any style, grits or hash browns, toast or biscuit

Two homemade crab cakes topped with our homemade shrimp sauce, eggs, cheese, and served with toast or biscuit

Ham can be substituted for bacon or sausage. Served with toast or biscuit.

American, Swiss, and Cheddar in a three egg omelette. Served with toast or biscuit.

Onion, bell pepper, mushroom, tomato, spinach, and cheese in a three egg omelette. Served with toast or biscuit.

Onion, bell pepper, mushroom, ham, hot sausage, pork sausage, bacon, and cheese in a three egg omelette. Served with toast or biscuit.

Shredded hash browns, chili, and cheese in a three egg omelette. Served with toast or biscuit.

Crawfish, onion, bell pepper, and cheese in a three egg omelette. Served with toast or biscuit.

Shrimp, onion, bell pepper, and cheese in a three egg omelette. Served with toast or biscuit.

Our homemade crab cakes in a three egg omelette. Served with toast or biscuit.

Bananas can be substituted for blueberries if available.

Bananas can be substituted for blueberries if available

Homemade white gravy over one of our biscuits. Sausage can be added to gravy for a little extra.

Homemade white gravy over our biscuits. Sausage can be added to gravy for a little extra.

Fried potatoes with onions and bell peppers

Choose sausage, ham, or bacon

Onion, Bell pepper, mushroom, tomato, and cheese in our shredded hash browns

A small order of grits

A large order of grits

A small order of oatmeal

A large order of oatmeal

A small order of our homemade shrimp & grits

A large order of our homemade shrimp & grits

Our best selling appetizer. Cut, battered, and fried to order. 15 thick rings served with our homemade onion sauce!

Another freshly cut, battered, and fried to order appetizer, served with our homemade onion sauce. Small...$6.95, Large...$9.00

Freshly cut, battered, and fried to order and served with our homemade onion sauce

Two homemade crab cakes topped with our shrimp sauce

Battered in house and served with ranch

A dozen locally made Tamales!

Turkey, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $10.00 full poboy...... $8.00 Short poboy, sliced bread or bun

Sliced roast beef, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato and gravy. $10.00 full poboy...... $8.00 Short poboy, sliced bread or bun

Ham, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $10.00 full poboy...... $8.00 Short poboy, sliced bread or bun

Our homemade burger, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $9.50 full poboy consisting of a pound of meat or $7.50 for a short poboy or bun consisting of a half pound of meat

Our homemade burger, cheese, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $10.50 full poboy consisting of a pound of meat or $8.50 for short poboy or bun consisting of a half of a pound of meat

Our homemade burger mixed with Patton’s hot sausage. Dressed with mayo, lettuce, pickle, and tomato. $11.50 full poboy consists of over a pound of meat. $9.50 short French or Bun consists of over a half pound of meat

Patton’s Hot Sausage, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $9.50 full poboy...... $8.00 Short poboy, sliced bread or bun

Smoked Sausage, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $9.50 full poboy...... $8.00 Short poboy, sliced bread or bun

French Fries, gravy, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $8.00 full poboy...... $6.00 Short poboy or bun

Fried shrimp, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $12.00 full poboy...... $10.00 Short poboy or bun

Fried catfish, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $9.50 full poboy...... $8.00 Short poboy or bun

Meatballs, red sauce, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $9.00 full poboy...... $7.00 Short poboy or bun

Caught in Saint Bernard and shredded ourselves! Soft shell crab, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $18.95 full poboy...... $12.95 Short poboy or bun

Ham, turkey, bacon, mayo, lettuce, tomato. Served with classic or barbecue lays, or substitute French fries for $1 more!

Double stacked bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. Served with classic or barbecue lays, or substitute French fries for $1 more

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on toast

BBQ beef, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $8.00 full poboy...... $7.00 Short poboy or bun

Fried or grilled pork chop, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $9.00 full poboy...... $7.00 Short poboy, sliced bread or bun

Breaded or grilled chicken breast, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $8.50 full poboy...... $6.75 Short poboy, sliced bread or bun

Hot dog and chili $7.00 full poboy...... $5.00 short poboy or bun

Castle burgers (aka Mini-burgers) dressed with ketchup, mustard, onions, and pickles. $9.00 per dozen..... $4.50 per half dozen..... .85 each

$6.95 full poboy.... $4.50 toast, bun, or short poboy

Ham can be substituted for sausage or bacon. $12.20 full poboy, $8.75 for toast, bun or short French

Strawberry, grape, or mixed fruit jelly

Our homemade crab cakes, mayo, lettuce, pickle, tomato. $20.95 full poboy...... $16.95 Short poboy, sliced bread or bun

Dressed with lettuce, tomato, pickle, and mayo. Full poboy $11.50..... Short poboy, bun, or sliced bread $10.00.

Dressed with mayo, lettuce, tomato, and pickles.

A large order of our homemade seafood gumbo

A small order of our homemade seafood gumbo

A large order of our homemade chicken & sausage gumbo

A small order of our homemade chicken & sausage gumbo

Large $5.50...... Small $3.50

Shredded lettuce and tomato with your choice of dressing on the side

Ham, turkey, roast beef, and cheese, with your choice of dressing on the side

Grilled or fried chicken, mushroom, onion, tomato, and cheese, with your choice of dressing on the side

Grilled or fried shrimp, mushrooms, onions, tomato, and cheese with your choice of dressing on the side

Fried or sautéed shrimp served with one side item, a garden salad, and toast. Add catfish...$4.50 Add a stuffed crab...$5.50 Add a soft shell crab...$9.95

Two Stuffed Crabs served with one side item, a garden salad, and toast. Add catfish...$4.50 Add shrimp...$4.50 Add a soft shell crab...$9.95

Fried Catfish served with one side item, a garden salad, and toast. Add shrimp...$4.50 Add a stuffed crab...$5.50 Add a soft shell crab...$9.95

Crabs caught in Saint Bernard and shedded here! Fried or Sautéed Soft shell served with one side item, a garden salad, and toast. One crab $22.95....... Two crabs $28.95

14 ounces of homemade hamburger steak smothered in grilled onions and gravy. Served with one side, a garden salad, and toast.

Chicken Fried Steak covered in our homemade white gravy served with one side, a garden salad, and toast

Two meatballs and spaghetti covered in red sauce and served with a garden salad

Two breaded or grilled pork chops served with one side, a garden salad, and toast

Fried chicken breast with red gravy and cheese on spaghetti. Served with a garden salad and toast.

One dark and one white piece of fried chicken served with French fries and toast.

Three Pieces of fried chicken served with French fries and toast

A breast, wing, leg, and thigh fried to perfection and served with French fries and toast

One breast and one wing fried to perfection and served with French fries and toast

Three pieces of fried breast and wings served with French fries and toast

Two breasts and two wings served with French fries and toast

One thigh and one leg served with French fries and toast

3 pieces of fried legs/thighs served with French fries and toast

Two thighs and two legs served with French fries and toast

For only white meat, add $3

For only white meat, add $5

For only white meat, add $5

For only white meat, add $5

For only white meat, add $5

For only white meat, add $5

For only white meat, add $7

For only white meat, add $7

For only white meat, add $7

For only white meat, add $7

For only white meat add $7

For white meat only, add $7

For only white meat add $10

Please give a few days notice if a bigger order is needed!

Butter, cheese, sour cream, bacon, and chives

Fried or grilled shrimp topping and loaded to your preference

Grilled or fried chicken topping and loaded to your preference

Patton’s hot sausage loaded potato

BBQ beef loaded potato

Four chicken nuggets served with French fries

Served with French fries

4 ounce homemade patty served on a bun with a side of fries

4 ounce homemade patty served on a bun with a side of fries

Hot Dog served on a bun with a side of fries

Hot dog and homemade chili served on a bun with a side of fries

Served with French fries

Regular or shoestring fries may be available

Regular or shoestring fries may be available

With or without gravy

With or without gravy

12 count

24 count

French Market

White milk or chocolate milk available

Apple juice, orange juice, or apple cranberry raspberry mix juice

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr Pepper, Hi C, Lemonade

Sweet or unsweetened

Glass bottle

Budweiser, Bud light, Miller Lite, Coors Light, Michelob Ultra

Water, Coke, Diet Coke, Coke Zero, Sprite, Diet Root Beer, Dr. Pepper, Diet Dr. Pepper, etc.

On Tuesday we serve all you can eat red beans and rice AND liver and onions. We usually have another option this day such as hamburger steak, meatloaf, or smothered pork chops if you’re not a fan of liver. Sides include mashed potatoes, veggies, cornbread, and dessert

Wednesday is red sauce day so we serve all you can eat Meatballs and spaghetti. We also do a second option on this day which may include lasagna, chicken parmesan, or occasionally stuffed peppers. This is served with veggies, cornbread, and dessert!

Thursday is one of our most popular buffets because we make the best fried chicken! Sides are different every week but could include homemade stuffings, pastas, dirty rice, baked mac, corn nuggets, onion rings, smothered okra, etc, etc! We try to keep three or four delicious sides out every Thursday. Don’t forget about dessert!

Friday’s Seafood buffet starts at $17.95 for lunch. This includes fried shrimp, fried fish, chicken & sausage gumbo, stuffings, pastas, etc and dessert. Depending on the season we will also have a boiled seafood buffet starting at 5pm. We boil crawfish, shrimp, and crabs relative to their season and prices vary depending on what they go for each year!